Full Text
Pioneer Village Living History Museum and Visitor’s Center Parks and Recreation Commission May 18, 2021 Oudens Ello Architecture Public Archaeology Laboratory Object IDEA Stimson ---PAGE BREAK--- Project and Team Introduction Interpretive Approach Pioneer Village Relocation and Visitor Center Program Camp Naumkeag Site Observations Site Planning Options Schedule and Funding AGENDA ---PAGE BREAK--- Matt Kirchman - Principal-in-Charge ObjectIDEA Visitor Experience / Interpretive Exhibitions Glen Valentine - Principal-in-Charge STIMSON Landscape Architecture Matthew Oudens, AIA, LEEP AP, MCPPO - Principal-in-Charge Oudens Ello Architecture Architecture / Prime Consultant Chris Genter, AIA, LEEP AP - Project Manager Oudens Ello Architecture Architecture / Prime Consultant Virginia Adams - Senior Architectural Historian The Public Archaeology Laboratory Architectural History / Regulatory Requirements Design Team ---PAGE BREAK--- Interpretive Approach ---PAGE BREAK--- Plymoth, Massachusetts Plimoth Plantation ❖First person living history 1620 village ❖Third person costumed contemporary Native homesite Interpretive Approach ---PAGE BREAK--- Valley Forge, Valley Forge ❖Propped cabins ❖Third person costumed contemporary interpreters ❖Graphics ❖Select “layers” of interp Interpretive Approach ---PAGE BREAK--- Shelburne, Vermont Shelburne Museum ❖Open and highly immersive structures ❖Third person docents / contemporary interpreters ❖Graphics / Exhibits Interpretive Approach ---PAGE BREAK--- Williamsburg, Virginia Colonial Williamsburg ❖Numerous options: costumed first-person guides, graphics, self-guided tools Interpretive Approach ---PAGE BREAK--- Interpretive Goals ❖Destination-quality interpretive program – What will be irresistibly compelling? ❖Year-round value – What will make the Village a real community resource? ❖Balance in the storyline – What are the narratives of Native peoples, settlers, the environment, and the historic village? ❖Contemporary relevance – What are the enduring ideas that the Village represents? Interpretive Approach ---PAGE BREAK--- Interpretive Approach ❖Decolonize – Expand the perspective beyond the dominant cultural group. Avoid a classic, singular “collision of cultures moment in time.” ❖Emphasize – Embrace sense of place and a broader environmental history. Explore ecological and cultural adaptations, and what it means to be native and non-native. ❖Democratize – Duality of identity: Naumkeag Cultural Center and Salem Pioneer Village (these are ideas, not names) ❖Contemporize – Illuminate how numerous cultures thrive on the north shore due to the riches that the environment provides Interpretive Approach ---PAGE BREAK--- Pioneer Village Relocation and New Visitor Center ---PAGE BREAK--- Pioneer Village 1 2 3 4 Photos 1930 ---PAGE BREAK--- 1 2 3 4 Photos 2021 Pioneer Village ---PAGE BREAK--- Program Visitor Center Exhibit 600 Classroom/ Temp Gallery 400 Restroom 120 Restroom 120 Lobby 400 Retail 150 Classrm. Stor. 50 Retail Stor. 50 Info/ Ticket Desk 50 Office 100 Break Room 150 Staff WC 60 Changing Room 60 Entry and Visitor Services Exhibit and Learning IT 50 Elec. 50 HVAC Water Fire Protection 150 Storage 150 Staff Service Public Restrooms Visitor Center 3,200 square ft. Outdoor Exhibit and Classroom Space ---PAGE BREAK--- Camp Naumkeag Site Observations ---PAGE BREAK--- Site Context Site Observations ---PAGE BREAK--- The Site Site Observations ---PAGE BREAK--- Present Day Site Aerial Fort Lee Dead Horse Beach Camp Naumkeag Site Memorial Drive Site Observations ---PAGE BREAK--- Memorial Drive Site Observations Site Model Aerial View ---PAGE BREAK--- Central Parcel Site Observations ---PAGE BREAK--- Central Parcel Site Observations ---PAGE BREAK--- Coastal Access Site Observations ---PAGE BREAK--- Coastal Bank Site Observations ---PAGE BREAK--- Eastern Parcel Site Observations ---PAGE BREAK--- Western Parcel Site Observations ---PAGE BREAK--- Site Planning Options ---PAGE BREAK--- Initial Planning Studies Site Planning Options Vistor Center Maintenance Facility Path to Dead Horse Beach Coastal Access Path Naumkeag Dwelling Village Entry Event Lawn 1 3 4 5 6 7 2 Pioneer Village Stormwater Garden 1 3 4 5 6 Vistor Center Maintenance Facility Stormwater Garden Restored Tidal Marsh Teaching Bridge Tidal Pool Boardwalk Naumkeg Fishing Weir Naumkeag Dwelling “Arabella” Pier Pioneer Village 2 Option A Option B ---PAGE BREAK--- Site Survey N Site Planning Options ---PAGE BREAK--- N Site Planning Options Visitor Center Locus of Indigenous Representation Parking Pioneer Village Event Area Site Plan Diagram ---PAGE BREAK--- Option 1 Site Plan Pavilion Event Area Wildflower Meadow Pioneer Village Field Animal Enclosure Meadow Hillside Amphitheater Stormwater Garden Visitor Center Informal Seating FEMA Zone VE Blacksmith Shop N Maintenance Shed Parking (10 cars) Trolley and Bus Drop-off Service/Event Access Tidal Marsh Access Service Access Site Planning Options Connection to Fort Lee ---PAGE BREAK--- Stormwater Management Site Planning Options ---PAGE BREAK--- Pavilion Event Lawn Wildflower Meadow Pioneer Village Field Animal Enclosure Meadow Visitor Center Informal Seating Blacksmith Shop N Maintenance Shed Parking (10 cars) Trolley and Bus Drop-off Service/Event Access Service Access Tidal Marsh Access Stormwater Garden Secure Perimeter Site Planning Options Hillside Amphitheater ---PAGE BREAK--- Pavilion Site Planning Options ---PAGE BREAK--- Existing Site Memorial Drive Site Planning Options ---PAGE BREAK--- Option 1 Aerial View Event Area Pioneer Village Memorial Drive Parking Trolley and Bus Drop-off Stormwater Garden Hillside Amphitheater Wildflower Meadow Blacksmith Shop Service Access Pavilion Green Roof Site Planning Options ---PAGE BREAK--- Option 1 Visitor Center Plan Diagram Event Area Pioneer Village Memorial Drive Parking Trolley and Bus Drop-off Stormwater Garden Wildflower Meadow Blacksmith Shop Service Access Pavilion Green Roof Site Planning Options Classroom Parking (10 cars) Trolley and Bus Drop- off Stormwater Garden Exhibit Lobby/ Retail Maintenance Hillside Amphitheater WC Mech Stor. +31 Hillside Amphitheater ---PAGE BREAK--- Option 1 Aerial View Event Area Pioneer Village Memorial Drive Parking Trolley and Bus Drop-off Stormwater Garden Wildflower Meadow Blacksmith Shop Service Access Pavilion Green Roof Site Planning Options Hillside Amphitheater ---PAGE BREAK--- Existing Site Memorial Drive Site Planning Options ---PAGE BREAK--- Option 1 Aerial View Event Area Pioneer Village Memorial Drive Parking Trolley and Bus Drop-off Hillside Amphitheater Coastal Bank Blacksmith Shop Service Access Meadow Wildflower Meadow Pavilion Green Roof Site Planning Options ---PAGE BREAK--- OPTION 2 Aerial View Event Area Pioneer Village Memorial Drive Parking Trolley and Bus Drop-off Stormwater Garden Wildflower Meadow Blacksmith Shop Service Access Pavilion Option 2 Aerial View Site Planning Options ---PAGE BREAK--- OPTION 2 Aerial View Event Area Pioneer Village Memorial Drive Parking Trolley and Bus Drop-off Stormwater Garden Wildflower Meadow Blacksmith Shop Service Access Pavilion Photovoltaics Option 2 Visitor Center Plan Diagram Site Planning Options Class- room Parking (10 cars) Trolley and Bus Drop- off Stormwater Garden Exhibit Maintenance Courtyard Maintenance Bathrooms Mech Stor. Lobby/ Retail +34 Porch ---PAGE BREAK--- Option 2 Aerial View Event Area Pioneer Village Memorial Drive Parking Trolley and Bus Drop-off Coastal Bank Blacksmith Shop Service Access Meadow Wildflower Meadow Pavilion ---PAGE BREAK--- OPTION 3 Aerial View Pioneer Village Memorial Drive Parking Trolley and Bus Drop-off Stormwater Garden Pavilion Wildflower Meadow Blacksmith Shop Service Access Pavilion Maintenance Shed Option 3 Aerial View Site Planning Options Woodland Amphitheater Event Area ---PAGE BREAK--- Woodland Amphitheater OPTION 3 Aerial View Event Area Pioneer Village Memorial Drive Parking Trolley and Bus Drop-off Stormwater Garden Wildflower Meadow Blacksmith Shop Service Access Pavilion Maintenance Shed Photovoltaics Roof Drains into Rain Garden Option 3 Aerial View Site Planning Options Class- room Parking (10 cars) Trolley and Bus Drop- off Stormwater Garden Exhibit Lobby/ Retail Maintenance Bathrooms and Staff Area Mech Stor. +36 Mech +Storage WC ---PAGE BREAK--- Option 3 Aerial View Event Area Pioneer Village Memorial Drive Parking Trolley and Bus Drop-off Coastal Bank Blacksmith Shop Service Access Meadow Wildflower Meadow Pavilion Maintenance Shed Site Planning Options Woodland Amphitheater ---PAGE BREAK--- Option 3 Aerial View Event Area Pioneer Village Memorial Drive Parking Trolley and Bus Drop-off Coastal Bank Blacksmith Shop Service Access Meadow Wildflower Meadow Pavilion Maintenance Shed Site Planning Options Woodland Amphitheater ---PAGE BREAK--- OPTION 3B Aerial View Event Area Pioneer Village Memorial Drive Parking Trolley and Bus Drop-off Coastal Bank Blacksmith Shop Service Access Meadow Wildflower Meadow Pavilion Maintenance Shed Green Roof Woodland Amphitheater ---PAGE BREAK--- OPTION 3 Aerial View Event Area Pioneer Village Memorial Drive Parking Trolley and Bus Drop-off Stormwater Garden Pavilion Wildflower Meadow Blacksmith Shop Service Access Pavilion Maintenance Shed OPTION 3B Aerial View Green Roof Class- room Parking (10 cars) Trolley and Bus Drop- off Stormwater Garden Exhibit Lobby/ Retail Maintenance Bathrooms and Staff Area Mech Stor. +36 Mech +Storage WC Photovoltaics Roof Drains into Rain Garden Woodland Amphitheater ---PAGE BREAK--- Classroom Parking (10 cars) Trolley and Bus Drop-off Stormwater Garden Exhibit Lobby/ Retail Maintenance Hillside Ampitheater WC Mech Stor. +31 Class- room Parking (10 cars) Trolley and Bus Drop-off Stormwater Garden Exhibit Maintenanc Courtyard Maintenance Bathrooms Mech Stor. Lobby/ Retail +34 Porch Option 1 Option 2 Option 3 Class- room Parking (10 cars) Trolley and Bus Drop-off Stormwater Garden Exhibit Lobby/ Retail Maintenance Bathrooms and Staff Mec h +36 Mech +Storage WC Visitor Center Options Site Planning Options ---PAGE BREAK--- Schedule and Funding ---PAGE BREAK--- 2021 2022 2023 2024 2025 2026 11 12 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 1 MASTERPLAN PHASE 1: Design PHASE 1: Construction PHASE 2: Design PHASE 2: Construction 1 Planning 2 SD SD 3 DD DD 4 CD CD 5 Bidding Bidding 6 Construction (12 months) Construction (14 months) Phase 1 Open 4 CD Move Historic Structures Exhibit Installation Phase 2 Open Phases 1 and 2 Schedule ---PAGE BREAK--- 1A Project Definition TASK 1: MASTERPLAN TASK 2: SCHEMATIC DESIGN 1B Data Collection and Analysis 1C Alternates 1E Final Report 2A Program Data Sheets 2B Schematic Design 1 Kick Off Meeting 3 Programming Order of Magnitude Estimates 9 Final Designs for Estimate 6 Design Options 5 Preliminary Design Options 2 Budget, Map out Stakeholder Outreach and Public Meetings, Preliminary Program Discussion 4 Programming 10 Estimate Review and Draft Report GLOBAL WORKSHOP Draft Review PAL Site Visit Geotechnical Investigation Construction Scenarios 2E Preliminary Meetings with Regulatory Agencies 2D Explore Funding Sources 2C Cost Estimate Estimate Reconciliation 11 SD Kick-Off Meeting 12 Design Meeting 13 Design Meeting 14 Design Meeting 15 Design Meeting 16 Estimate Review Issue Pricing Drawings 50% SD Drawings 100% SD Drawings Program, History, Site, Regulatory, Sustainability, Operating Cost, Code Massachusett Tribe Advisory Group Mtg. 1 Advisory Group Mtg. 2 Parks and Recreation Commission Mtg. 1 Parks and Recreation Commission Mtg. 2 6 Design Options 6 Design Options Historical Commission Engineering Department Fire Department 7 Design Options 8 Design Options 2020 2021 NOV DEC JAN FEB MAR APR MAY JUN WEEK 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 JUL 33 34 35 36 Masterplanning and Phase I Schematic Design Advisory Group Mtg. 1 Schedule ---PAGE BREAK--- Funding The funding for the project will be based on a mix of sources, including: • Community Preservation Act ($125,000 awarded to date), • Revenue from admissions, • Bonds, • Grant funding, and • Fundraising, which will be required to fully fund the Visitor Center The current estimated project cost is $3.9M