Full Text
0 $ $ $ $ 0 $ BID ALTERNATE 5 ARRA 8199(88) Sidewalk Ramps ‐ Missoula / City Project No. 09‐029 BID TABULATION BID OPENING: 4/5/2010 @ 1PM Engineer's Patterson Enterprises, Inc. Knife River LS Jensen Sirius Construction, Inc. Estimate Item Estimated Unit Unit Unit Unit Unit No. Description Quantity Unit Price Total Price Total Price Total Price Total Price Total BASE BID 1 Remove Curb 270 LF 5.00 1,350.00 $ 3.30 891.00 $ 16.50 4,455.00 $ 4.35 1,174.50 $ 15.00 4,050.00 $ 2 Remove 4" Sidewalk 1350 SF 2.50 3,375.00 $ 0.90 1,215.00 $ 4.50 6,075.00 $ 6.05 8,167.50 $ 4.46 6,021.00 $ 3 Remove Type Curb/Sidewalk 11500 SF 2.50 28,750.00 $ 0.90 10,350.00 $ 1.85 21,275.00 $ 3.25 37,375.00 $ 6.96 80,040.00 $ 4 Remove Asphalt 8740 SF 1.50 13,110.00 $ 1.00 8,740.00 $ 2.20 19,228.00 $ 1.05 9,177.00 $ 8.23 71,930.20 $ 5 Install Curb 270 LF 22.00 5,940.00 $ 17.40 4,698.00 $ 32.00 8,640.00 $ 23.30 6,291.00 $ 32.48 8,769.60 $ 6 Install 4" Sidewalk 1350 SF 7.50 10,125.00 $ 4.10 5,535.00 $ 8.50 11,475.00 $ 8.55 11,542.50 $ 5.22 7,047.00 $ 7 Install Type Curb/Sidewalk 11500 SF 8.50 97,750.00 $ 4.30 49,450.00 $ 5.65 64,975.00 $ 9.25 106,375.00 $ 8.70 100,050.00 $ 8 Install 3" Hot‐Mix Asphalt 8740 SF 3.50 30,590.00 $ 4.20 36,708.00 $ 2.70 23,598.00 $ 6.20 54,188.00 $ 4.64 40,553.60 $ 9 Install Truncated Domes 107 EA 200.00 21,400.00 $ 156.00 16,692.00 $ 149.00 15,943.00 $ 284.00 30,388.00 $ 377.00 40,339.00 $ 11 Place Top Soil 55 CY 30.00 1,650.00 $ 33.00 1,815.00 $ 25.00 1,375.00 $ 55.10 3,030.50 $ 69.60 3,828.00 $ 12 Traffic Control 1 LS 10,500.00 10,500.00 $ 8,000.00 8,000.00 $ 7,700.00 7,700.00 $ 14,000.00 14,000.00 $ 4,060.00 4,060.00 $ 13 Miscellaneous Work 5000 EA 1.00 5,000.00 $ 1.00 5,000.00 $ 1.00 5,000.00 $ 1.00 5,000.00 $ 1.00 5,000.00 $ SUBTOTAL 229,540.00 $ 149,094.00 $ 189,739.00 $ 286,709.00 $ 371,688.40 $ 14 R/W Permits @ 19% of SUBTOTAL 43,612.60 $ 28,327.86 $ 36,050.41 $ 54,474.71 $ 70,620.80 $ BASE BID TOTAL 273,152.60 $ 177,421.86 $ 225,789.41 $ 341,183.71 $ 442,309.20 $ BID ALTERNATE 1 1 Remove Curb 0 LF 5.00 ‐ $ 3.30 ‐ $ ‐ ‐ $ 4.35 ‐ $ 15.00 ‐ $ 2 Remove 4" Sidewalk 0 SF 2.50 ‐ $ 0.90 ‐ $ ‐ ‐ $ 6.05 ‐ $ 4.46 ‐ $ 3 Remove Type Curb/Sidewalk 6000 SF 2.50 15,000.00 $ 0.90 5,400.00 $ 1.85 11,100.00 $ 3.25 19,500.00 $ 6.96 41,760.00 $ 4 Remove Asphalt 2400 SF 1.50 3,600.00 $ 1.00 2,400.00 $ 2.20 5,280.00 $ 1.05 2,520.00 $ 8.23 19,752.00 $ 5 Install Curb 0 LF 22.00 ‐ $ 17.40 ‐ $ ‐ ‐ $ 23.30 ‐ $ 32.48 ‐ $ 6 Install 4" Sidewalk 0 SF 7.50 ‐ $ 4.10 ‐ $ ‐ ‐ $ 8.55 ‐ $ 5.22 ‐ $ 7 Install Type Curb/Sidewalk 6000 SF 8.50 51,000.00 $ 4.30 25,800.00 $ 5.65 33,900.00 $ 9.25 55,500.00 $ 8.70 52,200.00 $ 8 Install 3" Hot‐Mix Asphalt 2400 SF 3.50 8,400.00 $ 4.20 10,080.00 $ 2.70 6,480.00 $ 6.20 14,880.00 $ 4.64 11,136.00 $ 9 Install Truncated Domes 48 EA 200.00 9,600.00 $ 156.00 7,488.00 $ 149.00 7,152.00 $ 284.00 13,632.00 $ 377.00 18,096.00 $ 11 Place Top Soil 24 CY 30.00 720.00 $ 33.00 792.00 $ 25.00 600.00 $ 55.10 1,322.40 $ 69.60 1,670.40 $ 12 Traffic Control 1 LS 3,600.00 3,600.00 $ 4,000.00 4,000.00 $ 2,300.00 2,300.00 $ 3,500.00 3,500.00 $ 500.00 500.00 $ 13 Miscellaneous Work 1000 EA 1.00 1,000.00 $ 1.00 1,000.00 $ 1.00 1,000.00 $ 1.00 1,000.00 $ 1.00 1,000.00 $ SUBTOTAL 92,920.00 $ 56,960.00 $ 67,812.00 $ 111,854.40 $ 146,114.40 $ 14 R/W Permits @ 19% of SUBTOTAL 17,654.80 $ 10,822.40 $ 12,884.28 $ 21,252.34 $ 27,761.74 $ ALTERNATE 1 BID TOTAL 110,574.80 $ 67,782.40 $ 80,696.28 $ 133,106.74 $ 173,876.14 $ BID ALTERNATE 2 1 Remove Curb 0 LF 5.00 ‐ $ 3.30 ‐ $ ‐ ‐ $ 4.35 ‐ $ ‐ ‐ $ 2 Remove 4" Sidewalk 0 SF 2.50 ‐ $ 0.90 ‐ $ ‐ ‐ $ 6.05 ‐ $ ‐ ‐ $ 3 Remove Type Curb/Sidewalk 2250 SF 2.50 5,625.00 $ 0.90 2,025.00 $ 1.85 4,162.50 $ 3.25 7,312.50 $ 6.96 15,660.00 $ 4 h l Remove Asphalt 00 1500 SF 0 1.50 2 2 0 00 $ 2,250.0 00 1.00 00 00 $ 1,500.00 2 20 2.20 3 300 00 $ 3,300.00 0 1.05 00 $ 1,575.00 8 23 8.23 2 3 00 $ 12,345.0 5 Install Curb 0 LF 22.00 ‐ $ 17.40 ‐ $ ‐ ‐ $ 23.30 ‐ $ ‐ ‐ $ 6 Install 4" Sidewalk 0 SF 7.50 ‐ $ 4.10 ‐ $ ‐ ‐ $ 8.55 ‐ $ ‐ ‐ $ 7 Install Type Curb/Sidewalk 2250 SF 8.50 19,125.00 $ 4.30 9,675.00 $ 5.65 12,712.50 $ 9.25 20,812.50 $ 8.70 19,575.00 $ 8 Install 3" Hot‐Mix Asphalt 1500 SF 3.50 5,250.00 $ 4.20 6,300.00 $ 2.70 4,050.00 $ 6.20 9,300.00 $ 4.64 6,960.00 $ 9 Install Truncated Domes 18 EA 200.00 3,600.00 $ 156.00 2,808.00 $ 149.00 2,682.00 $ 284.00 5,112.00 $ 377.00 6,786.00 $ 11 Place Top Soil 9 CY 30.00 270.00 $ 33.00 297.00 $ 25.00 225.00 $ 55.10 495.90 $ 69.60 626.40 $ 12 Traffic Control 1 LS 1,950.00 1,950.00 $ 3,000.00 3,000.00 $ 1,500.00 1,500.00 $ 1,800.00 1,800.00 $ 500.00 500.00 $ 13 Miscellaneous Work 1000 EA 1.00 1,000.00 $ 1.00 1,000.00 $ 1.00 1,000.00 $ 1.00 1,000.00 $ 1.00 1,000.00 $ SUBTOTAL 39,070.00 $ 26,605.00 $ 29,632.00 $ 47,407.90 $ 63,452.40 $ 14 R/W Permits @ 19% of SUBTOTAL 7,423.30 $ 5,054.95 $ 5,630.08 $ 9,007.50 $ 12,055.96 $ ALTERNATE 2 BID TOTAL 46,493.30 $ 31,659.95 $ 35,262.08 $ 56,415.40 $ 75,508.36 $ BID ALTERNATE 3 1 Remove Curb 60 LF 5.00 300.00 $ 3.30 198.00 $ 16.50 990.00 $ 4.35 261.00 $ 15.00 900.00 $ 2 Remove 4" Sidewalk 300 SF 2.50 750.00 $ 0.90 270.00 $ 4.50 1,350.00 $ 6.05 1,815.00 $ 4.46 1,338.00 $ 3 Remove Type Curb/Sidewalk 2750 SF 2.50 6,875.00 $ 0.90 2,475.00 $ 1.85 5,087.50 $ 3.25 8,937.50 $ 6.96 19,140.00 $ 4 Remove Asphalt 2220 SF 1.50 3,330.00 $ 1.00 2,220.00 $ 2.20 4,884.00 $ 1.05 2,331.00 $ 8.23 18,270.60 $ 5 Install Curb 60 LF 22.00 1,320.00 $ 17.40 1,044.00 $ 32.00 1,920.00 $ 23.30 1,398.00 $ 32.48 1,948.80 $ 6 Install 4" Sidewalk 300 SF 7.50 2,250.00 $ 4.10 1,230.00 $ 8.50 2,550.00 $ 8.55 2,565.00 $ 5.22 1,566.00 $ 7 Install Type Curb/Sidewalk 2750 SF 8.50 23,375.00 $ 4.30 11,825.00 $ 5.65 15,537.50 $ 9.25 25,437.50 $ 8.70 23,925.00 $ 8 Install 3" Hot‐Mix Asphalt 2220 SF 3.50 7,770.00 $ 4.20 9,324.00 $ 2.70 5,994.00 $ 6.20 13,764.00 $ 4.64 10,300.80 $ 9 Install Truncated Domes 25 EA 200.00 5,000.00 $ 165.00 4,125.00 $ 149.00 3,725.00 $ 284.00 7,100.00 $ 377.00 9,425.00 $ 11 Place Top Soil 19 CY 30.00 570.00 $ 33.00 627.00 $ 25.00 475.00 $ 55.10 1,046.90 $ 69.60 1,322.40 $ 12 Traffic Control 1 LS 2,850.00 2,850.00 $ 3,000.00 3,000.00 $ 1,500.00 1,500.00 $ 2,700.00 2,700.00 $ 500.00 500.00 $ 13 Miscellaneous Work 1000 EA 1.00 1,000.00 $ 1.00 1,000.00 $ 1.00 1,000.00 $ 1.00 1,000.00 $ 1.00 1,000.00 $ SUBTOTAL 55,390.00 $ 37,338.00 $ 45,013.00 $ 68,355.90 $ 89,636.60 $ 14 R/W Permits @ 19% of SUBTOTAL 10,524.10 $ 7,094.22 $ 8,552.47 $ 12,987.62 $ 17,030.95 $ ALTERNATE 3 BID TOTAL 65,914.10 $ 44,432.22 $ 53,565.47 $ 81,343.52 $ 106,667.55 $ BID ALTERNATE 4 1 Remove Curb 40 LF 5.00 200.00 $ 3.30 132.00 $ 16.50 660.00 $ 4.35 174.00 $ 15.00 600.00 $ 2 Remove 4" Sidewalk 200 SF 2.50 500.00 $ 0.90 180.00 $ 4.50 900.00 $ 6.05 1,210.00 $ 4.46 892.00 $ 3 Remove Type Curb/Sidewalk 2250 SF 2.50 5,625.00 $ 0.90 2,025.00 $ 1.85 4,162.50 $ 3.25 7,312.50 $ 6.96 15,660.00 $ 4 Remove Asphalt 1780 SF 1.50 2,670.00 $ 1.00 1,780.00 $ 2.20 3,916.00 $ 1.05 1,869.00 $ 8.23 14,649.40 $ 5 Install Curb 40 LF 22.00 880.00 $ 17.40 696.00 $ 32.00 1,280.00 $ 23.30 932.00 $ 32.48 1,299.20 $ 6 Install 4" Sidewalk 200 SF 7.50 1,500.00 $ 4.10 820.00 $ 8.50 1,700.00 $ 8.55 1,710.00 $ 5.22 1,044.00 $ 7 Install Type Curb/Sidewalk 2250 SF 8.50 19,125.00 $ 4.30 9,675.00 $ 5.65 12,712.50 $ 9.25 20,812.50 $ 8.70 19,575.00 $ 8 Install 3" Hot‐Mix Asphalt 1780 SF 3.50 6,230.00 $ 4.20 7,476.00 $ 2.70 4,806.00 $ 6.20 11,036.00 $ 4.64 8,259.20 $ 9 Install Truncated Domes 20 EA 200.00 4,000.00 $ 156.00 3,120.00 $ 149.00 2,980.00 $ 284.00 5,680.00 $ 377.00 7,540.00 $ 11 Place Top Soil 10 CY 30.00 300.00 $ 33.00 330.00 $ 25.00 250.00 $ 55.10 551.00 $ 69.60 696.00 $ 12 Traffic Control 1 LS 2,100.00 2,100.00 $ 3,000.00 3,000.00 $ 1,500.00 1,500.00 $ 1,800.00 1,800.00 $ 500.00 500.00 $ 13 Miscellaneous Work 1000 EA 1.00 1,000.00 $ 1.00 1,000.00 $ 1.00 1,000.00 $ 1.00 1,000.00 $ 1.00 1,000.00 $ SUBTOTAL 44,130.00 $ 30,234.00 $ 35,867.00 $ 54,087.00 $ 71,714.80 $ 14 R/W Permits @ 19% of SUBTOTAL 8,384.70 $ 5,744.46 $ 6,814.73 $ 10,276.53 $ 13,625.81 $ ALTERNATE 4 BID TOTAL 52,514.70 $ 35,978.46 $ 42,681.73 $ 64,363.53 $ 85,340.61 $ BID ALTERNATE 5 1 Remove Curb 220 LF 5.00 1,100.00 $ 3.30 726.00 $ 16.50 3,630.00 $ 4.35 957.00 $ 15.00 3,300.00 $ 2 Remove 4" Sidewalk 1250 SF 2.50 3,125.00 $ 0.90 1,125.00 $ 4.50 5,625.00 $ 6.05 7,562.50 $ 4.46 5,575.00 $ 3 Remove Type Curb/Sidewalk 1250 SF 2.50 3,125.00 $ 0.90 1,125.00 $ 1.85 2,312.50 $ 3.25 4,062.50 $ 6.96 8,700.00 $ 4 Remove Asphalt 940 SF 1.50 1,410.00 $ 1.00 940.00 $ 2.20 2,068.00 $ 1.05 987.00 $ 8.23 7,736.20 $ 5 Install Curb 220 LF 22.00 4,840.00 $ 17.40 3,828.00 $ 32.00 7,040.00 $ 23.30 5,126.00 $ 32.48 7,145.60 $ 6 Install 4" Sidewalk 1250 SF 7.50 9,375.00 $ 4.10 5,125.00 $ 8.50 10,625.00 $ 8.55 10,687.50 $ 5.22 6,525.00 $ 7 Install Type Curb/Sidewalk 1250 SF 8.50 10,625.00 $ 4.30 5,375.00 $ 5.65 7,062.50 $ 9.25 11,562.50 $ 8.70 10,875.00 $ 8 Install 3" Hot‐Mix Asphalt 940 SF 3.50 3,290.00 $ 4.20 3,948.00 $ 2.70 2,538.00 $ 6.20 5,828.00 $ 4.64 4,361.60 $ 9 Install Truncated Domes 33 EA 200.00 6,600.00 $ 156.00 5,148.00 $ 149.00 4,917.00 $ 284.00 9,372.00 $ 377.00 12,441.00 $ 11 Place Top Soil 19 CY 30.00 570.00 $ 33.00 627.00 $ 25.00 475.00 $ 55.10 1,046.90 $ 69.60 1,322.40 $ 12 Traffic Control 1 LS 2,100.00 2,100.00 $ 3,000.00 3,000.00 $ 1,500.00 1,500.00 $ 2,700.00 2,700.00 $ 500.00 500.00 $ 13 Miscellaneous Work 1000 EA 1.00 1,000.00 $ 1.00 1,000.00 $ 1.00 1,000.00 $ 1.00 1,000.00 $ 1.00 1,000.00 $ SUBTOTAL 47,160.00 $ 31,967.00 $ 48,793.00 $ 60,891.90 $ 69,481.80 $ 14 R/W Permits @ 19% of SUBTOTAL 8,960.40 $ 6,073.73 $ 9,270.67 $ 11,569.46 $ 13,201.54 $ ALTERNATE 4 BID TOTAL 56,120.40 $ 38,040.73 $ 58,063.67 $ 72,461.36 $ 82,683.34 $ APPARENT LOW BIDDER: PATTERSON ENTERPRISES, INC. Bid Errors Noted: Highlighted cells show the corrected values from discrepancies found within the submitted bid sheets for each bidder.