Full Text
AGENDA TRI-COUNTY TECHNICAL ADVISORY COMMITTEE Friday, April 14, 2017* 10:00 A.M. KMPUD Community Services Building, Loop Road, Kirkwood, CA *NOTE: During the winter months, please check with the Alpine County Community Development Department at (530) 694-2140 to make sure the meeting has not been canceled due to inclement weather! The meeting can be viewed live at http://www.ustream.tv/channel/kmpud. The telephone number to call into the meeting is 1-[PHONE REDACTED]; use access code 480096. For further information on any of the agenda items, please contact Alpine County Community Development Department at (530) 694-2140. Off-agenda items must be approved by the Tri- County Technical Advisory Committee pursuant to Section 5496.5 of the Government Code. A. Call to Order B. Approve Agenda C. Correspondence D. Minutes: March 10, 2017 E. Public Matters: Information items and persons wishing to address the Committee regarding non-agenda items. F. Agenda Items: ITEM 1: Review and possible recommendation to the Amador County Planning Commission of a variance to the front yard building setback to allow construction of a garage, living space, and decks within 5 feet of the front property boundary located at 33905 Fremont Rd. Applicant: George and Sharon Bensch. APN: 026-172-014. G. Adjourn ---PAGE BREAK--- TO: PLANNING DEPARTMENT LAND USE AGENCY County Administration Center 810 Court Street· Jackson, CA 95642-2132 Telephone: (209) 223-6380 Website: www.amadorgov.org E-mail: [EMAIL REDACTED] APPLICATION REFERRAL Amador County Environmental Health Dept. Amador County Public Works Dept. Amador County Building Dept. Amador County Counsel Amador County Surveying Dept. KMPUD Volcano Telephone Company DATE: April 6, 2017 FROM: Amador County Planning Dept. PROJECT: Request by George & Sharon Bensch for a variance from County Code Section 19.24.040 which requires a 25-foot front yard building setback, in order to allow construction of an enclosed garage, additional living space, and decks within 5 feet of the front property/right-of- way line. The proposed garage would be located approximately 30 feet from the edge of pavement of Fremont Road. LOCATION: 33905 Fremont Road, Kirkwood, CA, (Lot 29, Kirkwood Meadows Unit 1) located approximately 650 feet west of the intersection with Kirkwood Meadows Drive. NOTE: This variance, if granted, will also require the abandonment of the 25' public utility easement located along the front lot line as noted on the subdivision map, and an encroachment permit for that portion of the driveway proposed to be located within the road right-oi-way. REVIEW: cc: file As part of the preliminary review process, this project is being sent to County staff and local agencies for their review and comment. The application will be reviewed by the Tri-County Technical Advisory Committee (TCTAC) on Friday, April 14, 2017 at 10:00 a.m. at the Kirkwood Meadows Public Utilities District Community Services Building on Loop Rd. in Kirkwood, California. The Amador County Technical Advisory Committee will review the proposed project application on Wednesday, April 19, 2017 at 2:00 p.m. at the County Administration Center, 810 Court St., Jackson, California. If the project application is complete, conditions will be formulated along with project recommendations and findings to be forwarded to the Planning Commission for their consideration. At this time staff anticipates the project will be Categorically Exempt from CEQA. Please forward your recommendations and/or concerns to the Planning Department as soon as possible. ---PAGE BREAK--- Sheldon Bidwell-Home Designer-CAD [EMAIL REDACTED] Jennifer Bidwell-Interior Designer j [EMAIL REDACTED] T. [PHONE REDACTED] wwwjenanndesigns.com 1772 D Street Suite 9 South Lake Tahoe, Ca 96150 D R AFT I N G Mailing-POBox9437SouthLakeTahoe,Ca96158 PROJf;CT TITLf; DATf; March 28, 2017 Bensch Kirkwood Addition CLlf;NT ILANDO'WNf;R Sharon Bensch 25050 No. Wild Hare Lane Acampo, Ca 95220 [PHONE REDACTED] [EMAIL REDACTED] PURPOSf; 0 = Rf;QUf;ST This letter will serve as a formal application for Variance 19.52.020 in which the adjustment will allow the addition of a new garage with living space above. Df;SCRIPTION VARIANCf; This project is intended to add a garage and additional living space to an existing structure and give a covered entrance from the outside to the inside of the home. The existing structure already sits 10' over the 25' front set back on the property. The garage addition is designed to tie into the existing home, the front elevation will continue 24' to the left (from the street view). At the longest point the garage addition will sit 17' into the 25' front setback line, still sitting behind the 5' front setback line. The new design and addition will upgrade all exterior siding and materials. The rustic, mountain design is Visually pleasing and is comparative to many of the neighboring homes. The design has been approved through the Kirkwood Meadows Planning Committee for preliminary review on October 29, 2016. RECEiVED Amador County MAR 3'1 2011 PLANNING DEPARTMENT ---PAGE BREAK--- Sheldon Bidwell-Home Designer-CAD [EMAIL REDACTED] Jennifer Bidwell-Interior Designer [EMAIL REDACTED] T. [PHONE REDACTED] wwwJenanndesigns.com 1772 D Street Suite 9 South Lake Tahoe, Ca 96150 D R AFT I N G Mailing-PO Box 9437 South Lake Tahoe, Ca 961 58 AMADOR COUN1Y PLANNING Df;PT County Administration Center 810 Court St Jackson, Ca 95642 [PHONE REDACTED] [EMAIL REDACTED] PRO-..Jf;CT TITL~ Bensch Kirkwood Addition CLI~NT/LANDO'WNf;R Sharon Bensch 25050 No. Wild Hare Lane Acampo, Ca 95220 209.481..6602 [EMAIL REDACTED] DATf; March 1.5, 201.7 Lf;TIf;R Of= AUT~OR IZAT ION TO Rf;PRf;SfNT f=OR A VARIANCf; This letter is to authorize JA Designs to represent Greg Bensch in the application process for a variance request through Amador County. A s;gn'tu",,4I~. ~ Date: 03/1612017 Sharon Bensch MAR 31 2017 PLANNING DEPARTMENT ---PAGE BREAK--- Sheldon Bidwell-Home Designer-CAD [EMAIL REDACTED] Jennifer Bidwell-Interior Designer j [EMAIL REDACTED] T. [PHONE REDACTED] wwwjenanndesigns.com 1772 D Street Suite 9 South Lake Tahoe, Ca 96150 D R AFT I N G Mailing-PO Box 9437 South Lake Tahoe, Ca 96158 t;;NVIORNMt;;NTAL INt=ORMATION 'WRITTt;;N PROJt;;CT Dt;;SCRIPTION PROJi;CT TITLi; DATt;; March 28, 20~7 Bensch Kirkwood Addition CLlt;;NT/LANDO'WNt;;R Sharon Bensch Lot 29, Kirkwood Meadows Unit No. ~ APN: 0 26 2- 0~4 33905 Fremont Rd Amador County, Ca. Kirkwood Meadows Plan [PHONE REDACTED] [EMAIL REDACTED] Existing Zoning District: R-:l/PD Existing General Plan: SPA List and describe any other related permits and other public approvals required for this project, including those required by city, regional, state and federal agencies: KMPUD new gas service to residence, proposed snow storage area. Site Size: ~2,789 Sq Ft. 2. Square Footage of Existing Residence: 2,367 Sq. Ft. Square Footage of Proposed Residence: 3,087 Sq. Ft. 3. Number of Floor of Construction: 2 Floors 4. Amount of Off-street Parking Provided: 2 car driveway. 5. Source of Water: KMPUD 6. Method of Sewage Disposal: KMPUD 7. See Attached Plans 8. Proposed Scheduling of Project Construction: Scheduled to start construction July 20~7 . 9. Development of project will not be constructed in phases. 10. No projects Associated with the project. 11. Subdivision/Land Division Projects: Not Applicable 12. This project is a single unit residential home. Range of sale price once complete $950,000-$115,000,000. Commercial Projects: Not Applicable ~4 . Industrial Projects: Not Applicable Institutional Projects: Not Applicable 16. This Project requires a variance. The existing structure already sits over the 25' front set back on the property. The garage addition is designed to tie into the existing home, the front elevation wi ll continue 24' to the left (from the street view). At the longest point the garage addition will sit into the 25' front setback line, still sitting behind the 5' front setback line. 17. -28. See Attached Additional Information Sheet. MAR 3 1 2.017 PLANNING DEPARTMENT ---PAGE BREAK--- ADDITIONAL INFORMATION: Are the following items applicable to tile project or its effects? Discuss below all items checked "yes" (attach additional sheets as necessary). YES NO 0 ~ 17. Change in existing features or any lakes or hills, or substantial alteration of ground contours. 0 ~ 18. Change in scenic views or vistas from existing residential areas, public lands, or roads. 0 ~ 19. Change in pattern, scale, or character of general area of project. 0 -r:I- 20. Significant amounts of solid waste or litter. 0 1'1. 21. Change in dust, ash, smoke, fumes, or odors in the vicinity. 0 22. Change in lake, stream, or ground water quality or quantity, or alteration of existing drainage patterns. 0 'J6 23. Substantial change in existing noise or vibration levels in the vicinity. 0 24. Site on filled land or has slopes of 10 percent or more. 0 25. Use or disposal of potentially hazardous materials, such as toxic substances, flammables, or explosives. 0 26. Substantial change in demand for municipal services (police, fire, water, sewage, etc.). 0 ~ 27. Substantially increase fossil fuel consumption (electricity, oil, natural gas, etc.) . 0 28. Does this project have a relationship to a larger project or series of projects? ENVIRONMENTAL SETTING 29. Describe the project site as it exists before the project, including information on topography, soil stability, plants and animals, and any cultural, historical or scenic aspects. Describe any existing structures on the site, and the use of the structures. Attach photographs of the site (cannot be returned). 30. Describe the surrounding properties, including information on plants and animals and any cultural, historical, or scenic aspects. Indicate the type of land use (residential, commercial, etc.), intensity of land use (one family, apartment houses, shops, department stores, etc.), and scale of development (height, frontage, setback, rear yard, etc.). Attach photographs of the vicinity (cannot be returned). 31 . Describe any known mine shafts, tunnels, air shafts, open hazardous excavations, etc. Attach photographs of any of these known features (cannot be returned). Certification: I hereby certify that the statements furnished above and in the attached exhibits present the data and information required for this initial evaluation to the best of ~ bilily, a that the facts, statements, and information presented are true and correct to the b s f my 0 ledge and belief. Date ~rZ.8-ll G:IPLANIWPDOCSIFormsIEnv Info Fonn .doc (Signatur~ ShtAyon ~SGh H!:i':I:i'fl:D l\,Ri <)1J(1 ~I MAR 31 2017 PLANNING DEPARTMENT ---PAGE BREAK--- Sheldon Bidwell-Home Designer-CAD donebidslt@yahoo,com Jennifer Bidwell-Interior Designer [EMAIL REDACTED] T. 530.600,2779 wwwjenanndesigns,com 1772 D Street Suite 9 South Lake Tahoe, Ca 96150 D R AFT I N G Mailing-POBox9437SouthLakeTahoe,Ca96158 29. Describe the project site as it exists before the project. The site is located on Lot 29, Kirkwood Meadows #1 @ 33905 Fremont Rd. in Amador County. The road is a public road with access to many surrounding residential properties. The topography of the site is sloped, the soil is stable and the plants and animals are native species. There is no cultural, historical, or scenic aspects to be considered on this property. There is an existing 2,367 Sg Ft. residential home with stained horizontal siding. 30. Describe the surrounding Properties. The surrounding properties are a ll single fam ily mountain homes. All surrounding properties are similar lot sizes. Most of the neighboring homes are visible from the property. The style of homes range from older mountain homes to newer, larger modern mountain homes. There are different species of pine trees in the area, specifically on this lot there are Fir Trees and Lodgepole Pines. This area is also inhabited by black bears, Northern Goshwaks, yellow bellied marmots, pika, snow plants, Tahoe yellow Cress to name a few. 31. Describe any known mine shafts, tunnels, air shafts, open hazardous excavations, etc. None that the applicants are aware of on the property. MAR 31 2017 PLANNING ---PAGE BREAK--- fROfOSED FRONT E[ REC8"ED Anradi! MAR 31 2017 PLANNING DEPARTMENT p Kirkwood . "'ciat~ Plan";"l.A /2'1/ k, l DATE ~J.t~ ---PAGE BREAK--- ---PAGE BREAK--- I LOT 28 \ 1 1-;;0 \ (Ii i, I:s, \0 Iz. \ ~ ~40"F . \ 1 \ LOT 41 LOT 30 PROPOSED SITE PLAN SCALE: 1" 10' ~ W ~ SL I 1 I I (TEMfJ @BEl 11010 SL 11010 SL 4e>4!1? SL I I ~ I I I . I I I I I I I I I I I I I - I BEDROOM 4 I x 10'T I ~ I BEDROOM 3 x B TH 2 10'" r: ~ I I 100 4$1====:1(110 V1I ~ 100 ~IO I I I I CLOSET 1 OlALCONY DN 13 RISERS "-bxb POST I : I CLOSET I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I ~ ~ _ ~!iL~L _ J EXISTING UFFER FLOOR FLAN REMAINS UNCHANGED Scale: 1/ (TEMP), TEMPERED GoLASS DECK (ABOVE) r STOR.AqE N STORAGE (RESIDENCE ABOVE) - f- f- 1 - ~ - ( ABOVE) bxb bxb POST POST GAME ROOM 21'S' X IS'S' 3!1?4!1? SL 3!1?4!1? SL 4!1?4!1?SL ( ELEC. METER , PANEL LOCATION X lL QI ::11 ~ ~ - ~ C ~ DN IS RISERS ~ SHELF +36' 21033 SL 4!1?4!1?SL I (TEMfJ 110hZ> SL WALL LINE (ABOVE) I ~ L1Y1~0x EXISTING MAIN FLOOR FLAN @BEl, TEMPERED GoLASS ~bXb I POST I 4030 SL I BEPROOM I 12'S' X 13'~' '1)'111. loY CLOSET G 'I)'lV _ - ' 32,.LD STOVE I I ~ eEPe~x~;?~ 2 i m! UPPER FLOOR, LIVING> AREA MAIN FLOOR, LIVING> AREA BASEMENT FLOOR. LIVING> AREA TOTAL LIVINGo AREA GoARAGoE AREA 4BS SF. 1,32~ SF. SS3 SF. 2,3b' SF. N/A 8i:(rJ~cD Arp:1J(;{ C( ~ tli"1~1 MAR 31 L017 en z :5 D- cr: o o CJ Z I- en W REVISION; SJB V' Z (J UJ o ---PAGE BREAK--- Sf rn ~ x ~ z Cl ?J rn » ?J rn I i I I o-d- . IJ-f (t t- tl .1,1- _ . 'l j . . I ~ , . I · II r rn ~ -l 0 z 1- + . ii ; l,c: 'IBI~ " _ . --~18f ·11 ; I t , T 1 - i+ · - I . ~ I II! I I I I I I , I I , I ! II I I I I I ) . tl~_ I ' [ I, I' : I: ~J j\'\I ~ iii ,i \I ll Iii ! ; i , , I! 1, . · ; 11 ~ 1 I : I! I I ! I Ii: ' I I ~ . I II: j I: ' ! II I: ! I ' ; I I , . , ! ; i , I: I : ~ i i ! \ "i \ ' , .11 ' , I 'I : 1: ' I, I 'i til ' : \ ' ; 'II, : ' I , : I ' , I I, Ii , " f I _ . . : 'II : i : iI ' . f :1 , • . " : i, ~ 1 , 'I I _ _ _ , I ' . , · ~ ,I , : , : [ , , ' , ; ! I i i ' _ . . I ! i ! i! Ii: l.j t , , II' I I I I i I 'I I : " : I' • ! I [ ! I I ! ( : 1.1, I ' ~ ii" I' Ii' I 1 ' , I: II II 1 ~ I I I ! , I 1 I I, ~ " I I J Iii f I I : I , ! : : i : i i I : i I I ,L I I I, i t _ . >3 : Ii,,· ! 1- , iii'!:: Ji : ' ,i I : • I( I i I I . I I i :11 I ' 1 I ! I I • I I ' , , . , . , _ j I I I I I I 1' 1: I ! : ' : . : I t ~ ! I , j Ii , I! \ I i I ' i I I" I ; I 'I ! . j I" j I I I i , I ' : I ; : ~ I \ \J z z Z o rn -u 1 I i , ! i 3> : iH~ ~ c f -Lt.. I I PROJECT FOR: GREG BENSCH 33905 FREMONT ROAD K IRKWOOD , AMADOR CO. CA 95646 AP N: 026- 172-014 ~ rn " x " - ~ (JI ~ -j z Cl r rn II -l rn r rn ~ 0 z ~ rn F. " X ~ (JI ~ -j z Cl II ?J 0 z -l rn r rn < » -l 0 z I I I I I I I I I I I I 1 - iA ~ ll il~I ' Il l l I ~illlj ii - . , . I , I I . .11 " i I I ) j I ; iiI i: I! r l " · . I I I I I I i I 'HE I ' I I I 1\ ! I :1 , , , , I~ , I I ! ~ i 1 I i I I I I I I I J I I i I I I I I I I EXISTING ELEVATIONS - SHELDON BIDWELL [PHONE REDACTED] OFFICE [EMAIL REDACTED] P.O. BOX 9' S. LAKE TA CA 96158 ---PAGE BREAK--- LOCKER ROOM x 6'6' GARAGE x 22'4' \ . ; / (N)I~1!12.0H GAf'-o' SUITE x 10'0' (TEMA (N)6Qb!).5L GL5 DOOR DN 1 RISERS 51-1ELF +.36' KITCHEN 12'1' x 11'0' ELEC.RANGE wIMICI'42' MECI-I CI-IASE PONY WALL POST ' " 11!' I ' I~ I' " " " , IT ' i i ,I I 11Lr -ll j r ; i 'M : :~,rwtl' U. ' I ~ I ~ 11!,m " I , PROJECT FOR: I 11, - - IH til III ,I ~ H II lI i~ 11 1 I,;B (I j I i 1'1 1:1 i:I r III ii' 11 /I I I I if I" 1i II \ ' B' ! I' . " i: I ' ,I " " , t f , v' ~ ~ LD !l f i: 1 ; , , , i I ~ i ii 'I ) i ' I II ' , " ~ r: I " , 8'-1' n"-go -0 r- Z Z ~ GREG BENSCH 33905 FREMONT ROAD KIRKWOOD, AMADOR CO . CA 95646 APN: 026' 172-014 PROPOSED ELEVATIONS Z G) CJ fTl ~ :D _ I ,.J1 W ~ 'So SHELDON BIDWELL [PHONE REDACTED] OFFICE [EMAIL REDACTED]